FYI: Science Policy News
FYI
/
Newsletter
The Week of January 9, 2023

What’s Ahead

Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) confers with Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL)

Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA), center right, confers with Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL), a key opponent of his bid to be speaker of the House. (Image credit – Andrew Harnik / AP)

House Leadership Deadlock Ends But Future Standoffs Likely

Last week’s deadlock over House leadership ended in the early hours of Jan. 7, when on their 15th vote members elected Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) as speaker by a razor-thin margin. To secure assent from holdouts in his party’s far-right flank, McCarthy made steep concessions, including allowing single members of his party to initiate votes to remove him. Hardliners are expected to try to force McCarthy into standoffs with the Democrat-controlled Senate and the Biden administration, particularly over budgets. If Democrats do not agree to sharply constrain spending , Republicans could threaten to shut down the government by not passing new appropriations legislation or decline to raise the federal debt limit, risking severe economic consequences. McCarthy has also promised far-right members three spots on the House Rules Committee, giving them sway over what proposals reach the floor and potentially making it more difficult to reach bipartisan agreements.

This week, the new House majority’s first step will be to adopt a rules package formalizing how it will run the chamber, including what constraints it will place on consideration of spending legislation. Disruptions stemming from standoffs or broad cutbacks in federal spending would certainly affect science agencies, despite the bipartisan buy-in for recent science policy initiatives such as the CHIPS and Science Act. Some particular science policy issues may also become the subject of controversy in ad hoc committees. Rep. Mike Gallagher (R-WI) is poised to chair a new committee on strategic competition with China that is likely to push additional restrictions on R&D exchanges with that country. Also, the existing coronavirus committee will change direction under Republican leadership, with attention focusing on topics such as the “lab leak” hypothesis of the pandemic’s origin, dangers associated with “gain-of-function” research, and the actions of Anthony Fauci , who has just retired as director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. The “climate crisis” committee the Democrats ran during the last two congresses will not continue and Republicans now plan to focus oversight on clean energy projects funded through the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act and the Inflation Reduction Act. They also plan to keep a close eye on the semiconductor initiatives funded through the CHIPS and Science Act.

In Case You Missed It

Secretary of State Antony Blinken at a meeting of the U.S.-EU Trade and Technology Council

Secretary of State Antony Blinken, center, at a December 2022 meeting of the U.S.-EU Trade and Technology Council. (Image credit – Commerce Department)

State Department Creates Emerging Technology Envoy Office

The State Department announced last week it has established an Office of the Special Envoy for Critical and Emerging Technology as part of a broader “modernization agenda” Secretary of State Antony Blinken is pursuing focused on technology diplomacy . The office’s aim is to be a “center of expertise and energy to develop and coordinate critical and emerging technology foreign policy, and to engage foreign partners on emerging technologies that will transform our societies, economies, and security — including biotechnology, advanced computing, artificial intelligence, and quantum information technologies.” The department has not announced who will be the special envoy but appointed as deputy envoy Seth Center, who previously worked as a historian at the National Security Council and as a senior adviser to the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence and the Special Competitive Studies Project . Despite his focus on emerging technology, Blinken has yet to appoint a science and technology adviser, a position the department created in 2000 to better incorporate technical expertise into its activities.

Intelligence Agencies Urged to Expand S&T Engagement

The National Academies released a report last month that identifies shortcomings in the ability of U.S. intelligence agencies to stay abreast of the latest advances in science and technology. The report’s primary recommendation is for the director of national intelligence to elevate attention to S&T across the intelligence community by appointing a chief technology and innovation officer, who would focus in part on coordinating R&D efforts across agencies and with outside organizations. Broadly, the report observes that the culture of secrecy at intelligence agencies can hamper access to cutting-edge research and it urges more engagement with researchers who primarily work in unclassified settings. It specifically proposes that intelligence agencies consider establishing more rotational positions that bring in scientists from academia and industry, including at the unclassified and secret levels since higher-level clearances can confer lifelong publication restrictions. It points to the CIA’s decision to establish a more open laboratory as a promising step and notes other intelligence agencies are considering establishing analogous labs. The report was developed by a 17-member committee chaired by Frederick Chang, chair of the computer science department at Southern Methodist University. In his preface, Chang explains that the report focuses on high-level organizational matters in part because a 2021 task force organized by the Center for Strategic and International Studies had already covered more detailed issues.

DARPA Funds New Microelectronics R&D Centers

The Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency announced last week that it is distributing about $230 million to create seven microelectronics research centers based at universities. Two of the centers will be hosted by Georgia Tech and the others are at Columbia University , Cornell University , Penn State University , University of California San Diego , and the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign . The grants kick off the second phase of the Joint University Microelectronics Program (JUMP), which is part of DARPA’s broader Electronic Resurgence Initiative.

NSF Selects Next Materials Research Division Director

The National Science Foundation announced last week it has selected Germano Iannacchione to lead the Materials Research Division within its Directorate for Mathematical and Physical Sciences. An expert in soft condensed matter with a doctoral degree in physics, Iannacchione has been a professor at Worcester Polytechnic Institute since 1998. He previously spent three years at NSF as a rotator overseeing the division’s condensed matter physics and biomaterials programs. Iannacchione will take over the role at the end of January from Linda Sapochak, who has led the division since 2016.

Events This Week

All times are Eastern Standard Time, unless otherwise noted. Listings do not imply endorsement.

Monday, January 9

American Astronomical Society: 241st meeting
(continues through Thursday)

American Meteorological Society: 103rd annual meeting
(continues through Thursday)

National Academies: Board on Science Education, meeting 38
(continues Tuesday)

White House: “Listening Session for the National Biotechnology and Biomanufacturing Initiative”
2:00 - 3:30 pm

Tuesday, January 10

NOAA: “New Technology for the Ocean Decade”
9:00 am

Brookings Institution: “The Future of the U.S.-China Competition for Human Capital”
10:00 - 11:00 am

CSIS: “Government Policies for Open Source Software”
10:00 - 11:00 am

Washington Post: “The New Space Age, with Johnson Space Center Director Vanessa Wyche”
4:00 pm

National Academies: “Confucius Institutes at U.S. Institutions of Higher Education,” report release briefing
4:00 - 5:00 pm

Wednesday, January 11

Hudson Institute: “Fighting China with Chips: U.S. Microelectronics Supplies During a Trade War”
10:00 - 11:00 am

CSIS: “Chip War: The Fight for the World’s Most Critical Technology”
10:30 - 11:30 am

NDIA: State of the Space Industrial Base”
10:00 am - 12:00 pm

Carnegie Endowment: “Technologies of Tomorrow: A Conversation with Eric Schmidt”
2:30 - 3:15 pm

Thursday, January 12

National Academies: “Biohybrid Materials and Technologies for Today and Tomorrow”
(continues Friday)

Aerospace Corporation: “Fact or (Science) Fiction of Space Diplomacy”
1:00 - 2:00 pm

National Academies: Nuclear and Radiation Studies Board meeting
1:00 - 4:30 pm

Friday, January 13

NSF: National AI Research Resource Task Force meeting
1:00 - 2:00 pm

Saturday, January 14

Atlantic Council: 2023 Global Energy Forum
(continues Sunday)

Opportunities

Federal Lab Assessment Board Seeking Members

The National Academies is seeking nine members for its Laboratory Assessments Board, which carries out technical reviews of national laboratories and other federal research facilities. Nominees should have expertise in laboratory management, program development, or the assessment of R&D activities. Nominations are due Jan. 13.

NASA Hiring Biological and Physical Sciences Head

NASA is hiring a director for the Biological and Physical Sciences Division within its Science Mission Directorate. With an annual budget around $85 million, the division supports research on how biological and physical systems respond to spaceflight environments in order to advance scientific discovery and enable space exploration. Candidates must have demonstrated experience managing a diverse portfolio of biological or physical sciences research programs. Applications are due March 3.

Input Sought on National Nature Assessment

The U.S. Global Change Research Program is seeking input to inform its first National Nature Assessment, which will “assess the status, observed trends, and future projections of America’s lands, waters, wildlife, biodiversity and ecosystems and the benefits they provide.” Specific benefits to be assessed include “connections to the economy, public health, equity, climate mitigation and adaptation, and national security.” USGCRP is specifically seeking input on potential audiences and uses for the assessment, as well as which questions and trends it should address. Comments are due March 31.

For additional opportunities, please visit www.aip.org/fyi/opportunities . Know of an opportunity for scientists to engage in science policy? Email us at fyi@aip.org .

Know of an upcoming science policy event either inside or outside the Beltway? Email us at fyi@aip.org .

Around the Web

News and views currently in circulation. Links do not imply endorsement.

White House

Quantum.gov: The National Quantum Initiative supplement to the president’s FY 2023 budget (report)

OSTP: Preparing US clinical trials infrastructure for emergencies: A White House virtual roundtable discussion

E&E News: White House releases latest regulatory plans

E&E News: White House releases climate guidance for permitting

Congress

CRS: Science and technology issues for the 118th Congress (report)

SpaceNews: Five Democratic senators seek funding boost for NASA and NSF astrophysics programs

E&E News: Senate Democrats’ agenda: Oversight, permitting, foreign affairs

Politico: New House select committee seeks ‘Cold War’ victory over China (interview with Rep. Mike Gallagher (R-WI))

Science, Society, and the Economy

Association of University Research Parks: The geography of technology, science, and innovation under the CHIPS and Science Act (report)

University of Chicago: UChicago launches Polsky Deep Tech Ventures to support startups bringing science, tech to market

New York Times: The dystopia we fear is keeping us from the utopia we deserve (perspective by Ezra Klein)

Education and Workforce

Science: Has China’s Young Thousand Talents program been successful in recruiting and nurturing top-caliber scientists? (paper by Dongbo Shi, et al.)

Times Higher Education: China’s Young Thousand Talents fails to attract ‘top scientists’

Nature: China’s Thousand Talents Plan to entice researchers home boosted their output

Law360: DOJ wants 30 months for chemistry professor Franklin Tao in ‘China Initiative’ case

Drugmonkey: On verifying eligibility under NIH’s Interest in Diversity

Research Management

Science|Business: NSF looks to shake up funding with ‘Golden Ticket’ pilot

Nature: ‘Disruptive’ science has declined — and no one knows why

Fortune: Why IBM is no longer interested in breaking patent records — and how it plans to measure innovation in the age of open source and quantum computing (perspective by Darío Gil)

New York Times: Asian researchers face disparity in winning grants from NSF

What’s New Under the Sun: Age and the nature of innovation

Nature: Unearned authorship pervades science

Science: Update to retraction policy (editorial)

Nextgov: NASA science directorate wants help prioritizing what digital resources it should open-source first

Issues in Science and Technology: When NASA collaborated with social scientists to engage the public in two-way conversations about the agency’s Asteroid Initiative, the outcome surprised everyone (perspective by Mahmud Farooque and Jason Kessler)

Labs and Facilities

The Guardian: International nuclear fusion project ITER may be delayed by years, its head admits

World Nuclear News: Russia has completed the draft design for a molten-salt research reactor

Albuquerque Journal: Los Alamos National Lab receiving record funding

CERN Courier: A new ATLAS for the high-luminosity era

CERN Courier: CMS prepares for Phase II

Honolulu Star-Advertiser: Thirty Meter Telescope environmental review delayed by voluminous comments

Planetary Radio: Jet Propulsion Lab director wants ‘every brain’ to have the chance to work in space exploration (audio interview with Laurie Leshin)

Computing and Communications

Bloomberg: Battered by COVID, China hits pause on giant chip spending aimed at rivaling US

EE Times: Experts: US military chip supply is dangerously low

Nature: Are quantum computers about to break online privacy?

Shtetl-Optimized: Cargo cult quantum factoring

HPCwire: Supercomputing’s critical role in the fusion ignition breakthrough

Space

SpaceNews: NASA planetary science budget remains under stress

South China Morning Post: Chinese scientists scramble to wake Mars rover, plan to use orbiter to investigate, sources say

SpaceNews: NASA faces budget crunch for extended Earth science missions

SpaceNews: Independent review warns of cost growth on key Earth science mission

NASA: Retired NASA Earth Radiation Budget Satellite reenters atmosphere

Washington Post: Starlink satellite trains: Is this the future of the night sky?

Ars Technica: So long, Sen. Richard Shelby (R-AL), and thanks for all the pork

Weather, Climate, and Environment

CRS: The US Geological Survey: Background and FY2023 appropriations

NESDIS: NOAA’s GOES-18 is now GOES West

Optics: NIST and NOAA upgrade ocean optical sensor

Colorado Sun: Better weather forecasts, and better alerts, are key to disaster response (perspective by Michael Glanz and Antonio Busalacchi)

Inside Climate News: NOAA climate scientists cruise Washington and Baltimore for hotspots — of greenhouse gases and air pollutants

Wall Street Journal: Will climate change really put New York underwater? (perspective by Steven Koonin)

Niskanen Center: Solar radiation management is here

Energy

Sifted: The EU delay on fusion is a scandal and a shame for an energy-embattled continent (perspective by André Loesekrug-Pietri)

Power: NuScale submits standard design approval application to NRC for uprated SMR design

New York Times: How a nuclear dump in Taiwan created a generation of activists

MIT Technology Review: Why 2023 is a breakout year for batteries

Bloomberg: China finds a place in US ‘battery belt’ with Ford, CATL deal (perspective by Anjani Trivedi)

E&E News: DOE eyes winners for nation’s first hydrogen hubs

Defense

Inside Defense: Pentagon wants Defense Innovation Board to assist in developing S&T strategy

Inside Defense: Shyu establishes ‘strategic investment capital’ task force at Defense Innovation Board

Defense News: Pentagon racing to restore US superiority in hypersonics

Reuters: Russian hackers targeted US nuclear scientists

Exchange Monitor: After ‘various delays,’ Livermore subcritical series to run through fiscal 2026

Breaking Defense: Sens. Reed (D-RI), Inhofe (R-OK) warn Biden AUKUS risks becoming ‘zero sum game’ for US Navy

Breaking Defense: Facing US lawmaker concerns, Australian prime minister defends AUKUS sub efforts

Biomedical

NIH: 2022: A year in review (perspective by Mike Lauer)

ARPA-H: ARPA-H selects Dr. Susan Monarez as deputy director

Inside Higher Education: Public health majors grow by more than 1,000%

Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists: Despite risk-management gaps, countries press ahead with new labs that study deadly pathogens (perspective by Matt Field)

New York Times: AI turns its artistry to creating new human proteins

International Affairs

University Affairs: New advisory panel hopes to bring fresh look at research support in Canada

Japan Times: US and Japan to expand cooperation on key technologies beyond chips

Nikkei Asia: US lawmakers outline next frontiers of China tech competition

South China Morning Post: Top engineers and scientists dying at an unprecedented rate in China after lifting of COVID controls

Times Higher Education: China’s eastern universities told not to poach from lagging regions

Financial Times: The UK’s dream of becoming a ‘science superpower’

Physics World: UK must embrace overseas talent to become a ‘science superpower’, says report

Research Professional: UK’s new biosecurity strategy ambitions need ‘realistic funding’

Research Professional: UKRI staff ‘at breaking point’ as strike ballot looms

Science|Business: Switzerland kicked out of European research infrastructure coordination body

CERN Courier: From dreams to beams: SESAME’s 30 year-long journey in science diplomacy

More from FYI
FYI
/
Article
NASA attributes the increased cost to pandemic-related disruptions and changes to the mission design.
FYI
/
Article
More than half of the money set aside for semiconductor manufacturing incentives has been awarded in the past month.
FYI
/
Article
Republicans allege NIH leaders pressured journals to downplay the lab leak theory while Democrats argue the charge is baseless and itself a form of political interference.
FYI
/
Article
The agency is trying to both control costs and keep the sample return date from slipping to 2040.
FYI
/
Article
Kevin Geiss will lead the arm of the Air Force Research Lab that focuses on fundamental research.
FYI
/
Article
An NSF-commissioned report argues for the U.S. to build a new observatory to keep up with the planned Einstein Telescope in Europe.

Sign up for FYI This Week, our weekly digest of science policy news.

By signing up you agree to allow AIP to send you email newsletters. You further agree to our privacy policy and terms of service.