We recently asked, “Artificial tree or real tree, and why?” Some of your responses:
Real. You can’t fake that smell. —Jim D.
A real tree is a ritual event: riding to the lot, walking around to find the right tree, watching it go through the net. Then tying it to the roof and hoping to get home before it tumbles off. Getting it perfectly centered in the holder with the best side facing the room. (Maybe a little arguing with the spouse.) Oh, and then the smell. Can’t be beat. —Ann W.
My grandmother’s aluminum Christmas tree is still going strong, with my three-year-old grandson hanging the ornaments on it this year. A classic! —Marcia W.
We had a live tree once. After Christmas we planted it in the backyard, and it lived twenty-nine years. But finding one was tough this year, and the thought of killing a healthy tree? Artificial it is! —Kelley B.
Both. We put up a faux tree in November and decorate it with everything but the kitchen sink. Then sometime in December, we buy a smallish real tree and just use white lights. I can’t give up the personality and the wintry smell of a live tree. —Donna G.
We have a ficus tree that we decorated for years. The kids loved showing it to their friends. —Louis G.
Artificial and pre-lit. It makes life easier—no watering, no mess. Just hang the ornaments and plug it in! —Debbie M.
Both. The main tree, the one the family gathers around for presents, has to be real. However, each room gets a tree, and those are fake. —Jacquelyn P.
Ever since my parents, one year, bought an aluminum tree and my mom sprayed Pine Sol to “have the real tree smell,” I can’t do anything but real. —Richard B.