Instead, Richard Warren, who was dining nearby, noticed the commotion and “Without hesitating a moment he dashed out of the house, throwing off his coat and shoes as he went, and…plunged into the water.” As he did so, he passed another would-be rescuer, Mr. R.E.L. Brown. Warren “reached the young lady about two hundred yards from the shore, just as she was giving up.”
Warren tried to return to the shore with Maffitt clinging to his shoulders, but the going was rough. It looked like they both might drown. According to the Wilmington Messenger, Carrie then declared “Mr. Warren, I do not think you can save me the waves are so high…It is not necessary that both should die. So, if you find yourself growing weak under the burden, turn me loose and let me die alone…” Instead, “the calmness and valor of the two” got the pair back to near the shore, where they were helped onto the land.